Though I love Crush 40, I chose Throw It All Away. 'cause c'mon that song is just so awkward and weird and awesome. Everett Bradley's voice is so awkward and great. :' Plus also because the SA2 theme was his debut theme as a character, so it kind of earns the right in that respect, to me at least.
However, I would choose (were it an option) All Hail Shadow. That song just plain rules. (Gotta go with the Magna-Fi version, because I don't like Crush 40's. Actually, I don't really like any of Crush 40's remixes. Their regular songs I like, though.)(Oh yeah. I think they're coming out with a couple of new albums. WOOT.)
mmm even thought new songs from the ShTH like "waking up" and "the chosen one" are awesome, idk why "I am... all of me" always steals the fame XD but still "trow it all away" suits shadow original character profile more than the others, so i stick into it
Anyway, if I analize the situation, I think the more appropiate one is 'Throw It All Away' because is the very first Shadow's theme. Nevertheless is cooler to me 'I Am... All Of Me', so I've voted for that one.
BTW, have you checked the Sonic Wrecks site lately...? *smiles with complicity*
Throw it All Away Newer Sonic fans probably have no god damn idea how sexy that song is <3 It doesn't need a bunch of lyrics to song godly. I Am...All of Me is emo shit IMO, although the newer Crush 40 version is ok. Like, the one in Sonic '06. ShTH version was crud I think lol
Oh, and the SA2 album was called Multi-Dimentional, according to Shadow of a Hedgehog, but there was also the Sonic Adventure 2 Vocal Album. But I'm being a picky bitch lol
I'd have to go for I Am, just because it rocks harder. Throw It All Away just sounds a little too genre-specific, only really appealing to the people into it. I Am has a nice rocking beat that probably appeals to a wider audience, and excuses the corny lyrics.
Im, ussuly, always with the classics. i mean, yeah, i like all the kick-ass guitar solos and bla blah but i also love the whole kinda trance/ electro mix. So i have to vote for SA2, throw it all away. :3